The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark The Legal Examiner Mark search twitter facebook feed linkedin instagram google-plus avvo phone envelope checkmark mail-reply spinner error close
Skip to main content

City Hall, San Francisco – At a special joint meeting of the Board of Supervisors and the Police Commission this past Thursday, concerned citizens packed the seats to speak out against the surge in the pedestrian fatality rate in the city. Although the high number of pedestrian fatalities sparked the meeting, the City also addressed concerns about bicycle injuries and particularly fatalities. Walk SF was there. The San Francisco Bicycle Coalition was there, and I was there. The City government seems to be listening and plans are being made to support the new zero tolerance policy for pedestrian fatalities. And we all received a hand out called “FOCUS ON THE FIVE” from the SFPD Chief. I will post soon on the contents of the handout and the information on which streets and intersections have the highest accident and injury rates in San Francisco.

The meeting, which was attended by the Chief of Police and both SFMTA Supervisors and Directors, focused primarily on the 25 traffic related fatalities in 2013, and what is planned in the upcoming year to greatly reduce those numbers.

David Campos, an SFMTA Supervisor, warned that the hearing should “Focus on how we can move forward without pointing fingers.”

Jane Kim, a San Francisco Supervisor in attendance, reaffirmed her commitment to pedestrian safety and reassured those in attendance that all guilty parties are “being prosecuted by the District Attorney”. Further, the presenters stressed that “the press plays a very important role in educating people about safety.”

Jikaiah Stevens, a pedestrian who was struck this past September in Nob Hill, also spoke out, stating that she wanted to “show a face to a system that doesn’t support its victims”.

Stevens was walking to work when she was hit by an oncoming car. A hairstylist and a photographer, Stevens lives paycheck to paycheck and cannot afford insurance. Although she has been able to go back to work, she cannot afford her medical bills, which total over $140,000.00. The motorist who struck her was not issued a citation

Many cite the lack of police officers and appropriate officer training, which in turn causes a drop in written citations, and can create a lax environment where pedestrians don’t feel accountable for violating the traffic laws. Likewise, when we make motorists less accountable this further contributes to less safe driving. I have always believed that personal liability and accountability are essential to reduce pedestrian and bicycle accidents.

“We are  hearing of people not being reported or given the required attention”, said Leah Shahum, of the SF Bicycle Coalition, a group pushing for “Vision Zero”, a campaign to put an end to pedestrian and bicycle fatalities in the city. The Bicycle Coalition pointed out that many bicycle accidents are not reported by the San Francisco PD. The City officials are promising better reporting, indeed that all bicycle accidents with injuries would be reported.

At the end of the hearing, Police Chief Suhr stated that Ms. Steven’s case would be reopened and the driver would be issued a citation, apologizing for the department’s handling of the situation.

I am pleased to see so many are speaking out against the staggering numbers of pedestrian fatalities in our city. Pedestrian safety is a problem that demands the attention and involvement of all City departments as well as safety groups advocacy groups and all citizens who share our streets . No entity or organization can put an end to the pedestrian or bicycle deaths by themselves, but a combined effort of police, government, and private organizations and citizens, will help reduce the casualties, and make our streets safer for everyone.


Hello, I’m Claude Wyle, a San Francisco automobile and pedestrian accident attorney. Have an idea for a topic you’d like to see covered here? Feel free to contact me: or visit


  1. Gravatar for sforick

    I fully support safe streets. As a driver, I constantly fear a collision with all of its physical and psychological consequences.

    The SFPD response to this is problem is laudable. The City now needs to go far further in its enforcement support by spending money now on overtime to support the enforcement effort. Simply bringing the police department back to full force over time is not enough. We need a real surge while the problem is on everyone’s mind. If the City was serious about enforcement and education, it would take a portion of its army of parking enforcement officers and dedicate them to street education and enforcement of bicycles and pedestrians allowing the SFPD to focus on vehicles. The parking enforcement officers have the appropriate vehicles and already are deployed across the city at curbside.

    The Engineering component is more problematic. SFMTA has taken away street design from professional engineering experts and made it a fragmented “community” and committee process at the will of politicians and lobbyists. The results are unsafe streets. Bicycles should be given routes of their own on a network of streets dedicated to bicycles and local traffic only. Mixing bicycles, cars, and buses on major streets (e.g. Van Ness, Division, 3rd, Potrero, Caesar Chavez, etc.) is dangerous. The street designs being rubber stamped all over the city under the euphemisms of “traffic calming” and “streetscaping” are misguided in their application. Studies have shown traffic calming costs over 4 lives lost through delayed emergency response for every pedestrian saved, yet our politicians fight input to these projects by SFFD. These lives lost are as important as those of pedestrians. I am an engineer and I believe in engineering solutions, not political solutions. Let engineering do its job if you want better safety

  2. Gravatar for Ikwon

    Agree with sforick's comments above. I am a very seasoned and high mileage urban cyclist and a card carrying. Bike Coalition member. I also drive a car in the city (I have two kids who attend two separate schools both in opposite directions from our home). Cyclist should have a separate routes on less busy streets. I love fellow riders who use hand signals, use lights and helmets and ride predictably. I disown the militant riders who wear their headphones with no safety gear and yell "F*%# You!" to those who call them out for riding on sidewalks or blowing stop signs. Same goes for bad drivers who speed and don't give cyclists a safe distance and anyone talking or texting while operating anything with wheels.

Comments are closed.

Of Interest